J.J. Spaun’s Caddie Under Fire As Costly 17th Hole Advice Gifts Rory McIlroy $4.5M at The Players Championship

Rory McIlroy secured his second PLAYERS Championship title, but controversy overshadowed the final moments. J.J. Spaun’s caddie, Mark Carens, faced backlash for advising an aggressive approach on the 17th hole. The risky decision led to Spaun overshooting the green, costing him a chance at victory. Fans also accused Carens of attempting to gain an unfair advantage by peeking at McIlroy’s club selection, a move that ultimately backfired.

The misstep has left Spaun and his supporters wondering what could have been. He had been playing some of his best golf and had strong crowd support heading into the playoff. However, the crucial mistake shifted momentum in McIlroy’s favor, allowing him to claim the $4.5 million prize. Frustrated fans have called out Carens, blaming his poor judgment for Spaun’s missed opportunity.

Speculation is now growing over Carens’ future as Spaun’s caddie. Many believe Spaun will part ways with him after the costly blunder. Social media reactions have been harsh, with some calling the decision-making “unprepared” and “reckless.” As McIlroy celebrates his win, Spaun is left to reflect on a tournament that slipped through his fingers.